People have to guess what you do? How to fix your website

Published November 21, 2026 · 5 min read

Headshot of Stefanie Kruse
Stefanie Kruse Creating websites solopreneurs can run themselves · 10+ years in design and tech.

You send someone to your website and hear nothing back. Every call starts with you explaining what you offer. And when AI describes your business, it could be describing anyone.

The result is what I call website cringe: you hesitate every time you share your link. Something’s off, but you can’t say what, so reworking your website stays on your to-do list.

Sometimes the cringe is about the look, when your branding feels off. This post is about the other kind: your website looks fine, but people still don’t get what you do.

You know what’s behind every term. Your visitors don’t. And because every offer feels important to you, your website tries to say everything at once.

The problem: you can’t read the label from inside the jar.1

Illustration of a person inside a glass jar, facing the back of its label, while another person outside holds up a mirror. Visualizing David C. Baker’s quote, "You can’t read the label from inside the jar." Artist unknown.

This matters more as your business grows. Strangers and AI find you on their own, and both read your website without context.

Once your website is clear, you can share your link without hesitating. And visitors can tell within seconds whether you’re the right fit. Here are 3 ways to get there.

Strategy 1: Test your website on people who don’t know you

You can’t see your own website the way a stranger does. So ask strangers. A quick test shows how good your website is at explaining what you do. One of my clients ran this test by accident: a prospect scrolled through his old website and narrated how lost she was.

Nothing like watching someone get lost on your digital doorstep to wake you up. — Dror Yaron, Leadership Coach

You can do the same on purpose: it’s called the 8-second test. You find 5 people who fit your audience but don’t know your work. You ask them to look at your homepage for 8 seconds (without scrolling). Then they answer 3 questions:

  1. What does this business do?
  2. Who do they work with?
  3. Why would you trust them?

Listen for 2 things: vague answers and hesitation. “Something with coaching?” means your website hasn’t said it yet. “Leadership coaching for founders” means it has. If people have to guess, so do your future clients.

Good to know: search engines and AI bots read your website the same way, without context. Words a stranger can repeat, AI can repeat too. That’s also how you show up in AI search.

The test shows where your words fall short. Finding better ones is the next step.

Strategy 2: Listen for the words your clients use

The best words for your website come from your clients. They describe your work from the outside. And that’s just what your future clients will understand best.

After a few years in business, you’ll find client language in many places:

  • how they describe their problem on a first call (your call transcripts help, if you record)
  • how they introduce you when they refer you
  • testimonials, emails, and thank-you notes

The phrases that come up again and again are the ones that belong on your website.

This is also where professional copywriters start. Some go further with voice-of-customer research. No copywriter yet? With The reLaunch, I bring one in and manage the project.

Clear words help with every offer. If you have several, there’s one more thing to sort out: how visitors find the one that fits them.

Strategy 3: Give people three doors, not twenty

If you show a bunch of offers, you make it harder for visitors to find theirs. A service page with 6 offers side by side asks them to compare all 6 before they know which one fits. Many won’t: they skim, feel unsure, and close the tab. Psychologists call this choice overload. Too many options lead to no choice. It gets worse in a navigation menu, where you only show offer names without context.

This mistake usually comes from a good place: you want people to see everything you do.

My Three-Door Framework reduces that choice. Visitors see 3 clear paths, each with one offer or offer group, and pick the one that fits them. The goal isn’t to oversimplify your work. It’s to make the first decision easy.

Your 3 doors can follow different lines. Some examples:

  • Mode of delivery: done for you, done with you, and done by you
  • Client types: solopreneurs, small businesses, and larger companies
  • Client needs: coaching for individuals, groups, and teams
  • Service depth: project work, ongoing support, and one-off sessions

On your website, the doors can show up in several places, such as 3 cards in the services section of your homepage, 3 items in your navigation, and one page per door with the details.

Project Insight: Ethics.Coach

Dror’s brief listed 6 coaching offers. We grouped them into 3 doors by client needs: 1:1, group, and team coaching. One offer, a complimentary session, left the website altogether: Dror offers it on a call when he feels a fit.

The homepage cards and the navigation follow the same paths.

A row of cards showing the three coaching offers. When a user hovers over the cards, they rotate slightly, giving the site a playful vibe.

Since the reLaunch, his sales calls have shifted from explaining his offers to refining fit. Or, as Dror puts it:

The old site asked visitors to figure out if we were a fit. The new one? It helps you feel it.
— Dror Yaron, Leadership Coach

Read how Dror’s reLaunch came together

If you book a reLaunch like Dror did, we use the VIP Strategy Day to work out the best path through your offers before any design starts.

Clear words, sorted offers. One question tends to come up at this point.

Can’t AI make my website clear for me?

AI works fast, but it only knows what you tell it. If you can’t see your business objectively, neither can AI: it’s inside the jar with you. It hands your own words back, just more polished. Or it fills the gaps with phrases that could describe anyone.

An AI-edited play on the uncredited illustration visualizing David C. Baker’s quote, "You can’t read the label from inside the jar." This time, it's not only a person in the jar, but a robot symbolizing AI that can't help you read the label.

Where AI does help is the legwork: digging through call transcripts, testimonials, and emails for the phrases your clients repeat.

Tired of explaining what you do on every call?

The 8-second test shows you what’s unclear. Your clients’ words show you what to say instead. What neither can show you is how to present several offers, maybe to different audiences, on one website.

A reLaunch takes care of all of it, from your structure to your copy.

Just need an outside view? I’ve got you covered. I’ve spent 10+ years making digital products easy to use. In a Strategy Session, we spend an hour on your biggest website challenge. I review your website before the call and document everything afterward, so you walk away with a clear plan of what to change.

It’s not a sales call where I’d talk you into a reLaunch. It’s one hour of strategy for €200, and you make the changes yourself.

Book a Strategy Session

Sources

  1. The phrase was popularized by David C. Baker in his book The Business of Expertise. ↩︎

The Website Shift

Like what you’re reading?

Subscribe to The Website Shift for more perspective shifts that make your expertise visible, credible, and profitable.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Five solopreneurs who are subscribed to the newsletter.

Trusted by expert solopreneurs around the globe.

By subscribing, you agree to receive informational and promotional emails from reThink the Web. Unsubscribe at any time via the link in each email. Find all details in my privacy policy.