Is Substack worth it for solopreneurs? 10 reasons to think twice
Published November 13, 2026 · 7 min read

Substack looks like the obvious home for your writing: free, set up in an afternoon, and everyone you follow seems to be there.
So, should you use Substack or your own website?
It depends on what your writing is for. If you’re a writer or journalist whose newsletter is the business, Substack’s network and community can carry you far.
This post is for you if you run an independent business selling your expertise. You want to publish long-form writing without hassle, reach inboxes, or both. Your blog or newsletter is a marketing tool, maybe with paid subscriptions on the side.
For you, there are better options. Substack is built to grow Substack. Its business model, app, and feeds pull your readers away from your business.
I’ve never published on Substack, but solopreneurs ask me about it often. So I rounded up what its writers report: 10 reasons to think twice, and what to use instead.
New to Substack? Start with the quick answers. Know the basics? Jump to Substack’s red flags.
Note: Platforms change often. All details in this post are as of the publishing date.
Quick answers about Substack
Now for the 10 reasons.
1. Substack platforms and pays Nazi publications
In November 2023, The Atlantic reported Nazi and white-supremacist newsletters on Substack, some earning money from subscriptions. Nearly 250 writers signed an open letter asking why. Co-founder Hamish McKenzie answered, “we don’t like Nazis either,” but Substack would only remove them for credible threats of violence. Around 100 other writers signed a counter-letter backing that stance: Substack shouldn’t decide what people read.
The problem stayed. In July 2025, Substack sent app users a push alert promoting a Nazi newsletter, then called it “an error.”
On Substack, your writing helps fund the same platform that hosts, and pays, Nazis. Whether that fits your ethics and your positioning is your call.
2. Substack isn’t an email marketing tool
To bring in clients, your emails need to do more than deliver posts. A welcome sequence tells new subscribers who you are and what you offer. Segments and automations send each reader the right emails at the right time, like a launch.
Substack sends your posts, but doesn’t move readers toward working with you. Its few preset automations turn free readers into paid subscribers, which serves Substack more than your marketing.
3. Substack moves your readers from email into its app
Email reaches readers directly, without an algorithm. Substack keeps moving them into its app instead. Subscribers who switch get notifications instead of emails. And new readers who hit “follow” never make it to your list.
A reader in Substack’s app is Substack’s reader. Your email list goes with you if you leave. Followers stay behind.
4. Your writing builds Substack’s brand, not yours
Every Substack looks like a Substack: a few layouts, a few font choices, your logo and colors. Readers may remember Substack more than you.
Your posts also live apart from what you sell. When readers finish one, Substack points them to its feed, app, and other publications. Readers who love your post should be one click from your offers, not from the next Substack.
For SEO nerds: why Substack ranks, not you
Every post on Substack teaches search engines to trust substack.com, not your website. Some AI answers draw on those results, too.
Substack already has plenty (it scores 94/100 for domain authority on Ahrefs). Your website needs that trust to show up in searches for your topic or services.
A paid custom domain only partly helps. Your website already uses your main address, so Substack runs on a subdomain like newsletter.yourdomain.com. Trust built there doesn’t reliably reach your service pages.
None of this is surprising, given what Substack’s investors expect.
5. Substack’s investors need your audience to pay off
Substack runs on venture capital. In July 2025, it raised another $100 million at a $1.1 billion valuation, with annual revenue reported at around $45 million. Investors who pay that much expect a much bigger company.
That growth has to come from writers and readers: more time in Substack’s feeds, more of your income through its cut, and more reasons not to leave. It’s the Big Tech playbook, with algorithms deciding who sees your posts. Many people start a newsletter to escape exactly that.
The next reasons show that playbook at work.
6. Substack turned into another social feed
Substack started as a newsletter tool. Today, much of its growth runs through Notes, a Twitter-like feed of short posts. To show up in Substack’s feeds, you keep Notes fed.
Some writers love it. Others left over it, like one writer who moved to Patreon in 2025: “With their hard pivot to Notes and the Substack App, the brand has decided to focus on turning readers into social media consumers.”
As a solo business owner, you might not like where that leads: “I went from writing for the social media algorithm (LinkedIn mainly) into burnout,” says a fellow solopreneur about Substack.
You wanted a home for your thinking. You got another algorithm to feed.
7. Substack’s discovery promise fades after the honeymoon
Discovery is Substack’s biggest promise: new readers find you through its network. Substack says its recommendations drive half of all new subscriptions. Writers tell a different story.
One writer watched the numbers grow while the newsletter got weaker. She told Nieman Lab: “I was getting tons of new free subscribers but my open rates were tanking, my paid conversions were flat.” The reason: “When I left Substack a few thousand of my subscribers were bots and junk.”
And the push doesn’t last. Another writer told The Verge: “When I first joined up, [Substack] gave me a big push and featured me… But once I wasn’t one of the ‘new recruited talent’ they could tout, they stopped featuring me and I saw my growth stagnate.“
Discovery isn’t unique to Substack. Real newsletter tools have it, too. Read on for alternatives.
8. Substack takes a 10% cut of every paid subscription
On a paid newsletter, Substack keeps 10% of every subscription. Add Stripe, and almost 14% goes to fees. Ghost, beehiiv, and Buttondown take 0% on top of payment processing.
That adds up fast. One paid newsletter writer paid $4,968 a year on Substack, and $2,052 after moving to Ghost.
Share your expertise for free, and you’ll never pay the 10%. But the business model shows whose interests come first: Substack earns when writers sell subscriptions, not when your expertise brings you clients. With venture capital behind it, every feature gets built for that.
9. Substack locks you in, and then changes the rules
On Substack, how your readers pay you is Substack’s decision. You can only accept subscription payments through its platform.
And Substack changes the rules. In 2025, it turned on iPhone in-app payments for all paid newsletters. Those run through Apple, which takes up to 30%: either iPhone readers pay more, or you earn less.
Leaving is possible: you can export your posts and subscribers. But paid subscriptions cause problems.
- Paid through Apple: readers must cancel and resubscribe on your new platform, and some won’t.
- Paid through Stripe: Substack’s 10% keeps running on every renewal after you leave, until you ask its support to remove it.
Which brings us to our last problem: support.
10. Substack’s support is mainly bots
Even top writers found support reduced to a bot in 2025. One wrote: “No one was getting my newsletter. There was no tech support. The people who couldn’t get the newsletter were forced to read it on the app.”
Substack claims its support chatbot solves about 90% of issues. If it can’t help, your issue becomes an email ticket.
And the reply may not come from a person either: when tech journalist Timothy B. Lee emailed support in 2024, “Lily” sent a five-paragraph reply within a minute and wouldn’t say whether AI wrote it.
Substack alternatives for your newsletter and writing
If Substack works for you, there’s no rush to leave. Deciding where to start, or thinking about a move? Here are my recommendations. Lex Roman’s How to leave Substack in 10 easy steps walks you through the move.
For a paid newsletter
Many writers who left Substack moved to these platforms:
- Ghost: open source, run by a non-profit, 0% fees.
- beehiiv: 0% on paid subscriptions, only payment processing fees.
- Buttondown: a small, independent tool that takes no cut of paid subscriptions.
- Patreon: a membership platform for newsletters, podcasts, and more.
For free newsletters and email marketing
An email tool you own does what Substack can’t: lead your readers to your offers. Welcome sequences, segments, and automations are built in. Your list stays yours, with no app or algorithm in between. Popular options, all with free plans:
- Kit: a recommendation network where other creators send readers your way.
- beehiiv: built-in growth tools like recommendations and a referral program.
- MailerLite: easy to use and based in the EU.
- Ecosend: the more sustainable choice, running on renewable energy and offsetting carbon.
For your thought leadership
I firmly believe your long-form writing belongs on your own website. There, every post builds your site’s trust, sits next to your offers, and leads readers to your list. It’s why Independent Technology is one of the 5 Solopreneur Website Foundations.
That doesn’t mean skipping LinkedIn or Medium. I compare LinkedIn and Medium vs. your own blog, and share my recommended setup: website, email list, and platforms working together, so you get their reach without the risks.
Maybe you’re thinking, “My website fights me on every edit. Why would I blog there?” I hear that from solopreneurs all the time. It doesn’t have to be that way.
The reLaunch gets you a website where you write your post right in WordPress, paste it from your writing tool, or let AI help, if you like. A new post means adding your words, not designing a page.
The Website Shift
Like what you’re reading?
Subscribe to The Website Shift for more perspective shifts that make your expertise visible, credible, and profitable.
No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
Trusted by expert solopreneurs around the globe.