Your AI-built website looks great. That’s exactly the problem.

Published April 9, 2026 · 7 min read

Headshot of Stefanie Kruse
Stefanie Kruse Creating websites solopreneurs can run themselves · 10+ years in design and tech.

Update, October 2026: This post was lightly edited for readability.

You built your website with Cursor, Lovable, Claude, or another AI tool. You shared it on LinkedIn, and the comments rolled in: “Looks amazing!” “So clean!” “AI is the future!”

Everyone was looking at the design. Nobody checked under the hood. So I did, for 10 AI-built websites: a friend’s site that I checked as a favor, and nine that people proudly shared on LinkedIn.

I found the same problems in every single one: slow pages, tracking without consent, missing security basics, and rookie mistakes in accessibility and SEO. None of it shows in the design, so you’d need to know where to look.

October update incoming!

The new edition of this audit with fresh data and insights on the visuals of AI-built website is coming out soon. Subscribe to the Website Shift newsletter to get it first.

Aside from the update you’ll get one practical insight or perspective shift every Monday, to make your expertise visible, credible, and profitable. 

Five solopreneurs who are subscribed to the newsletter.

Trusted by expert solopreneurs around the globe.

By subscribing, you agree to receive informational and promotional emails from reThink the Web. Unsubscribe at any time via the link in each email. Find all details in my privacy policy.

What’s going wrong under the hood of AI-built websites

These problems aren’t technical nitpicks. Each one affects whether your business gets clients, gets found, or stays out of legal trouble. And they’re connected: a site with bloated images loads slowly, ranks lower, and emits more carbon.

Infographic analyzing 10 AI websites on LinkedIn. Highlights issues: privacy, security, carbon footprint, speed, SEO, and accessibility, with many sites rated poorly. Full results in the following text.

For each category below you’ll read: what’s at stake for your business, what I found across the 10 sites, and what’s causing it.

Speed: only 1 site loaded in under 3 seconds

Your website has about 3 seconds to load before visitors start leaving. At 5 seconds, the chance they leave is 90% higher than at 1 second.1

Only 1 out of 10 sites loaded in under 3 seconds on mobile, Google’s recommended threshold. Three took over 8 seconds. “But everyone has fast internet in 2026,” I can hear you say. Not on Deutsche Bahn WiFi. Not in a cafe with 30 people sharing one router.

The main cause: heavy, unoptimized images, uploaded straight from the camera, way too large for a screen (1,920 pixels wide is all you’ll ever need). Unused code and a 1 MB font file add to the weight. AI doesn’t question any of this. You upload a photo, it places it at full size.

Speed lowlight: one site had a 4 MB logo. Another had 21 MB of images on a single page.

CO2 emissions: most sites above the global average

The heavier your site, the more energy each page view uses, and the slower it loads.

Only 4 out of 10 sites came in below the global average of 0.41 g of CO2 per page view. The other 6 ranged from 0.44 g to 2.36 g. The heaviest site was dirtier than 97% of all websites.2

The cause is the same as with speed: huge images, fancy animations, and heavy JavaScript. That’s what AI produces when you prompt for a “sleek” or “modern” website. And because AI makes “more” cheap and easy, you keep adding sections, images, and effects. Nobody checks the weight.

SEO: rookie mistakes that cost you search traffic

SEO decides whether people find you on Google and in AI search at all. SEO problems are silent: you don’t see the traffic you’re not getting.

6 sites had SEO scores below 100, ranging from 75 to 92. That looks adequate, but anything under 100 means a rookie mistake:

  • Missing meta descriptions on 5 sites. This is the text Google shows under your page title. Without one, Google pulls random text from your page.
  • Broken or invalid robots.txt files on 2 sites. This small file helps search engines crawl your pages. If it’s broken, Google might not index your site at all.
  • Links that search engines can’t follow on 1 site. They look clickable to you but are invisible to Google.

Most business owners don’t know that a meta description or a robots.txt exists. You can’t prompt for something you’ve never heard of.

Accessibility

Accessibility isn’t just about people with disabilities. Low contrast affects people over 40 and anyone reading in bright sunlight, and small buttons frustrate everyone on a phone. Search engines and AI bots read your site like a screen reader, so what locks out visitors also locks out search.

Lighthouse accessibility scores ranged from 87 to 96. Those numbers sound reassuring. They’re not. Automated tests only catch surface-level issues. Here’s what the scores were hiding:

  • Contrast issues on 6 out of 10 sites: text that’s hard or impossible to read against its background.
  • Heading order problems on 5 sites: screen readers use headings to navigate a page. When levels are skipped, navigation breaks down.
  • Missing main landmarks on 4 sites: without them, screen reader users have to wade through every element to find the content.
  • Small touch targets on 2 sites, and buttons without accessible labels: a sighted user sees a button, a screen reader user hears nothing.

Accessibility lowlight: black text on a dark green background, on the main call-to-action button in the mobile menu. Nobody can read it, and the owner never checked the site on a phone.

AI doesn’t catch these issues because it builds what it has seen: almost 96% of the top 1 million websites have accessibility errors, 56 per page on average.3 More on how accessibility helps you reach more clients.

Privacy: 9 out of 10 sites tracked visitors without consent

If you’re in the EU or serve visitors there, the GDPR applies to your website. A missing privacy policy can mean fines of up to 4% of your annual revenue, and in some countries, like Germany, tracking without consent alone can cost up to €300,000. “I didn’t know” is not a defense.

9 out of 10 sites tracked visitors without consent. They loaded Google Fonts or other Google services from Google’s servers, sending every visitor’s IP address to Google. Only one site was clean.

9 out of 10 had no proper privacy policy. Three sites also set third-party cookies, and only one of those had a cookie policy.

Privacy lowlights: one privacy policy link led to a 404 error page. Another site had a footer label that said “Privacy,” but it wasn’t even a link.

Security: every site was missing the basics

Getting hacked costs time, money, and reputation. If your site stores personal data, even just contact form submissions, a breach becomes a privacy violation, too.

Every single site was missing security basics: none had all security headers in place. Two sites scored a B, one an F, and the rest a C or D.4 While everyone’s complaining about how insecure and easy-to-hack WordPress is, nobody seems to care about what AI does.

Why AI keeps making these mistakes

These aren’t random oversights. They’re systemic, and they come down to three things:

  1. AI is a copycat. It reproduces patterns from millions of websites, and most of those don’t meet modern standards. The result isn’t a bad website. It’s the average of what exists online, not the quality your business needs.
  2. AI gives you what you prompted. Nothing more. You didn’t prompt “add a privacy policy,” “compress all images,” or “add security headers.” It won’t flag that your 4 MB logo should be 4 KB.
  3. You can’t catch what you don’t know to look for. You may not know to check your mobile menu, that your fonts send visitor data to Google, or that your site is one complaint away from a GDPR fine.

“If you don’t know what quality output looks like, AI won’t save you. […] AI only makes sense if you use it to amplify what you already know and do well, not as a hack.”

I use AI in my own design workflow, and so do many designers. The difference: we know what to direct it to do, what to check, and what to fix. One website shows what that difference looks like.

AI-built vs. professionally built: one website, side by side

Can AI build your website? My friend’s one-page site gives a clear answer: halfway. She built it with Claude Code, and I checked it through the 5 Solopreneur Website Foundations. Strategy, branding, and user experience held together. Technology and ethics told a different story.

Infographic comparing a one-page website built with Claude Code to one built by reThink the Web, rated across the 5 Solopreneur Website Foundations. See the full image description below for details.
Full image description

Headline: “Claude vs reThink websites.” Two one-page websites, rated across the 5 Solopreneur Website Foundations:

  • Strategic Clarity: excellent for both.
  • Professional Branding: good for the Claude Code site, excellent for the reThink the Web site.
  • Intuitive User Experience: excellent for both. A note explains that clarity and UX mainly worked because the owner used my Solopreneur Website Blueprint to structure and write the page.
  • Technology: the Claude Code site rates satisfactory for security, needs work for SEO, and insufficient for performance, with 14.3 seconds load time on mobile. The reThink the Web site rates good for security, excellent for SEO and performance, with 2.8 seconds.
  • Ethics & Sustainability: the Claude Code site needs work on accessibility and is critical on data privacy. At 2.36 g of CO2 per page view, it gets an F, dirtier than 97% of web pages, and isn’t hosted green. The reThink the Web site is excellent on accessibility and data privacy. At 0.02 g of CO2, it gets an A+, cleaner than 98% of web pages, on green hosting.

A side note: you can get a one-pager with branding, copywriting, and a custom web design and build in as little as one week, at €2,500.

  • Speed: her site took 14.3 seconds to load on mobile. My builds average 2.8 seconds.
  • Carbon: 2.36 g of CO2 per page view, dirtier than 97% of websites. My builds average 0.02 g, on 100% renewable hosting. She works with clients in the sustainability space, so those numbers matter.
  • Privacy: Google Fonts tracked every visitor. No cookie banner, no privacy policy.
  • SEO: no meta description. My friend didn’t know what that was.

On top of that: the same accessibility issues and missing security headers as on every other site. Claude flagged none of it.

How to get the website basics that AI won’t check for you

es, AI can build you a website. It won’t make sure it loads on Deutsche Bahn WiFi, shows up in Google, stays legally sound, and can be read by people and bots alike. Those things are basics, not a bonus. And not even every web design freelancer gets these right.

If you want your website to bring in clients, not just compliments, it has to be built on the strong foundations a solopreneur website needs.

Every website I build has all the foundations in place from the start, whether you’re just starting out with The Website Sprint or replacing a site that no longer keeps up with your business through The reLaunch.

Are we a fit? Let’s find out in a free 30-minute Clarity Call.

You can find information on how your data is processed in my privacy policy.

Sources

  1. Source: Google/SOASTA Research, 2017 via Abralytics ↩︎
  2. The Website Carbon Calculator methodology is explained on their site. The checks were carried out on April 1, 2026 (no joke) using the v4 of the Sustainable Web Design Model (SWDM). For the global average, last reported numbers at Website Carbon were from 2023. So, I looked at the 2026 State of the Web report to calculate a median weight for all websites tested (weighted average for both desktop and mobile) and ran that trough the SWDM v4. This is what produced the 0.41 g of CO2 average. ↩︎
  3. I used the tool securityheaders.com. ↩︎
  4. Source: The WebAIM Million (The 2026 report on the accessibility of the top 1,000,000 home pages) ↩︎

The Website Shift

Like what you’re reading?

Subscribe to The Website Shift for more perspective shifts that make your expertise visible, credible, and profitable.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Five solopreneurs who are subscribed to the newsletter.

Trusted by expert solopreneurs around the globe.

By subscribing, you agree to receive informational and promotional emails from reThink the Web. Unsubscribe at any time via the link in each email. Find all details in my privacy policy.